Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem has sharply criticized New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani over a video advising immigrants on how to interact with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), arguing the guidance could cross constitutional and legal boundaries.
Speaking on Fox News’ Hannity, Noem accused some politicians of encouraging behavior that undermines law enforcement and puts public safety at risk.
“We would be ashamed of our kids for acting the way that these grown adults act,” Noem said, referring to political leaders she believes implicitly encourage hostility toward ICE agents.
What Noem says is the issue
Noem suggested that if Mamdani were to assume mayoral office, his actions could potentially violate the Constitution by encouraging people to evade law enforcement.
“If he were mayor, he could be violating the Constitution by giving advice on how to evade law enforcement and how to get away with breaking the law,” she said.
Her comments come amid rising tensions between federal immigration authorities and sanctuary jurisdictions, particularly New York City.
What Mamdani’s video says
The video, posted Sunday, outlines what Mamdani describes as immigrants’ legal rights when interacting with ICE officers. In the clip, he states that ICE agents cannot enter homes, schools, or private workplace areas without a judicial warrant signed by a judge.
“We can all stand up to ICE if you know your rights,” Mamdani says in the video. He also advises residents to keep doors closed if officers do not present a valid judicial warrant.
Mamdani further claims that ICE officers are “legally allowed to lie,” urging individuals to remain silent and ask, “Am I free to go?” if detained. He also states that residents may film ICE activity, provided they do not interfere with enforcement operations.
Context: protests and sanctuary policy
The video follows demonstrations in Lower Manhattan after several ICE arrests last week. Mamdani has said his incoming administration, if elected, would protect the rights of all New Yorkers — including the city’s estimated 3 million immigrant residents.
He has publicly committed to maintaining New York City’s sanctuary policies and has stated that he raised concerns about deportations directly with U.S. President Donald Trump.
Broader political clash
The exchange highlights growing friction between federal officials and local leaders over immigration enforcement. While Noem argues that such messaging undermines the rule of law, Mamdani and his supporters frame the guidance as basic legal education and civil rights awareness.
As immigration continues to dominate national politics, the debate is likely to intensify — particularly in major cities with large immigrant populations.
